Forgot Password

If you have forgotten your password, you may reset it here.

Outer Loop Closing Permanently to Vehicles for Safety

Point Defiance Park

Outer Loop of Five Mile Drive Closing to Vehicles Permanently for Safety

Download the 130-Page Geotechnical Report

Tacoma, WA: After careful consideration, and following a recent geotechnical report confirming ongoing erosion and slope instability, Parks Tacoma is closing the Outer Loop of Five Mile Drive in Point Defiance Park to all motorized traffic due to safety concerns.

The closure is effective beginning Friday May 20, 2022.

Bicycles, pedestrians and other non-motorized traffic will still be permitted to use the road, which winds around the tip of Point Defiance. Walking trails and restrooms will stay open. The closure spans the 2.25-mile distance between the entry/exit to Owen Beach and Fort Nisqually Living History Museum, including the Vashon Island, Dalco Passage, Gig Harbor, Narrows and Bridge viewpoints.

Five Mile Drive and TrailsBoth Owen Beach and Fort Nisqually will remain accessible along the Inner Loop of the Drive, with Owen Beach reopening in June after renovations.

The closure comes after thoughtful review of a recent geotechnical slope assessment commissioned by Parks Tacoma, that confirms ongoing erosion and encroaching instability on the bluffs edging the road around the point. Climate change is a global phenomenon that is having a clearly visible effect on shorelines and slopes in the Pacific Northwest, as heavier rain and sea level rise accelerate erosion and landslides. Parks Tacoma has been monitoring climate change impacts for years and working to make parks more resilient, including recent renovations to prepare Owen Beach and Dickman Mill Park for sea level rise.

Upon receiving the report, Parks Tacoma immediately eliminated use of heavy vehicles, including Tacoma Public Schools buses serving students at the Science and Math Institute inside the park. Vehicles over 8,000 pounds were restricted from entering. The agency also initiated the process for a third-party peer review of the report to affirm its findings.

outer loop bluffs comparison

The Outer Loop bluffs in 2005 (left, image courtesy The News Tribune) and in 2022 (image courtesy GeoEngineers)

Five Mile Drive has always been a place of beauty and peace for the community, serving as a refuge for many during the pandemic and beyond. Parks Tacoma kept it open while waiting for the second report results to allow access times for motorized and non-motorized users, and to explore possibilities for establishing a bypass route. However, with the imminent increase in park traffic after Memorial Day, Parks Tacoma believes it is important to close the Outer Loop now to all motorized traffic to prevent further slope damage and threat to public safety.

The road remains open to non-motorized users, as well as the formal trails, which are fenced well back from the cliff edge. For their personal safety and to mitigate human impact to the bluffs, visitors are reminded to regard all posted signs and security fences, remain on marked and maintained trails and remember that like any natural area, Point Defiance Park is a dynamic landscape and users should respect the conditions of that environment.

While reducing vehicular use of the Outer Loop is a part of the community-guided 2015 Point Defiance Master Plan Update, Parks Tacoma also realizes how important forest access is for those with limited mobility. However, pulling the roadbed back from the edge as conceptualized in the 2015 plan has been determined to be inadvisable. Meeting current design and permit standards with the 150-foot setback recommended by the January geotechnical report would require removal of a large number of trees, along with significant understory habitat. This would be contrary to Parks Tacoma’ stewardship commitments and the park’s biodiversity corridor designation

.biker biking on Five Mile Drive

The agency is exploring possibilities for re-establishing a route for motorized access by using an existing service road on the peninsula. If viable, this 1.5-mile alternative – which is currently closed to the public and bisects the tip of the peninsula – is thought to require far less modification, impacting fewer trees and associated habitat. Staff are also assessing ways to develop an accessible connection between the new upper Owen Beach parking area and the non-motorized Outer Loop experience to provide access for those with limited mobility.

“Parks Tacoma’ decision to close the Five Mile Drive Outer Loop was not undertaken lightly,” said Joe Brady, deputy director of regional parks and attractions. “We know how deeply our community feels about this tranquil, forested space. But we also take public safety and environmental protection very seriously. This decision is a direct response to the acceleration of erosion caused by multiple forces of nature, and we must respect that inevitable power.”

historic aerial park shot

A 1987 aerial shot of Point Defiance Park, showing existing cliff erosion. Photo credit: Christopher Petrich and Jerry Timmons (his pilot)

Point Defiance Slope Erosion Geotechnical Report (pdf)

Media Contact: Nancy Johnson

Frequently Asked Questions

Why didn’t you close the Outer Loop before this?

Parks Tacoma has been monitoring the eroding bluffs for years, taking actions to protect the public and slow the erosion. We know how important it is as a place of beauty and peace for all, and by moving fencing, adding signage and limiting vehicle hours we’ve been able to keep it open for safe access.

After receiving the January geotechnical report, we took time carefully assessing, initiating a peer review and exploring the possibility of enhancing an existing bypass service road, as it would have been ideal to have this in place before closure. We learned that, based on the need for engineering, permitting, funding and construction, this would be a multi-year initiative. With increased summer traffic approaching, we knew it was safest to close the road now to protect visitors and the slope.

Nobody knows when that cliff might suddenly give way, and our primary goal is to keep park visitors safe, as well as making our parks more resilient to climate change.

Is the Outer Loop still safe for bicycles and pedestrians?Automobiles need paved surfaces, and it’s that surface that is in danger that cannot be feasibly relocated without significant impact to the forest and its understory. We can’t upgrade this road safely, so we are closing it to vehicles to keep everyone safe. Walking/riding trails can be more easily altered to make them safer, and we are currently doing that on the Outer Loop.

We know how important Five Mile Drive is as a place of beauty and peace for all. But everyone needs to remember that this is a dynamic natural environment, and to respect all fences and signs and stay on marked trails.

How long will the drive through the park now be?

The distance of Five Mile Drive is measured from a plaque in the parking lot of Point Defiance Zoo & Aquarium. While the closure spans a 2.25-mile distance between the entry/exit to Owen Beach and Fort Nisqually, the Inner Loop of the Drive will still offer a 2.8-mile drive through the park.

Will there be any alternative access to the viewpoints for people with mobility issues?

We know how important the Outer Loop is as a place of beauty and peace for all our community. We are exploring possibilities for creating a route with nearby parking for those with mobility issues to gain safe, user-friendly access for a non-motorized experience on the Outer Loop. This could include a bypass road, and/or ADA-accessible routes or parking close to that unique forest experience. Parks Tacoma is committed to accessibility and inclusivity, while keeping people safe in our parks in balance with stewardship of the park’s rare urban ecosystem. This closure is one stage in the planning process designed to get us to long-range, accessible, equitable and environmentally sustainable solutions.

Where do I park to access the closed section on foot/bike/wheelchair?

Owen Beach is reopening June 4 with a new entry/exit road. Visitors can park in the new upper section to access the Outer Loop.

Are e-bikes and scooters allowed?

Yes. Bicycles (including electric bikes and scooters), pedestrians and other nom-motorized transport is allowed. Motorcycles, cars and other motorized traffic is not.

Can we still drive to Fort Nisqually? How will we get there?

Yes, visitors can still easily drive to Fort Nisqually Living History Museum. From the intersection at the entry to Owen Beach (near the Outer Loop gate closure) take a left to follow the Inner Loop. Keep right and follow signs to the Fort.

When and why did Five Mile Drive Closures first begin?

  • 2008: Vehicle-free hours first introduced, closed to cars before 10am for walkers and cyclists to engage safely and peacefully with nature.
  • After a surge of requests to expand non-motorized access, Drive closed Saturdays and Sundays until 1pm in six-month pilot.
  • 2009: After positive survey feedback, those hours fully adopted.
  • 2010-2015: Parks Tacoma receives increasing requests to further expand vehicle-free hours for added pedestrian/cyclist safety, including in 2015 Master Plan Update.
  • 2017-2020: Pilot weekday morning closures until 10 am and expanded weekend closures until 2pm. After positive community surveys, expanded hours are adopted.
  • March 2020: Pandemic forces a complete closure of most park assets to help slow the spread of COVID-19. Closures remain due to severe staffing shortages.
  • August 2020: Drive reopens for vehicles on weekdays only. Parks Tacoma begins planning efforts for pedestrian safety improvements based on Master Plan Update. Operations adapted in response to drastic revenue losses. Drive is open 9am-2pm weekdays.
  • January 2022: Parks Tacoma commissions updated geotechnical assessment of Outer Loop bluffs in preparation for safety improvements planned for viewpoints and Outer Loop Trail. The report confirms ongoing, accelerated erosion of the slope and increasing encroachment of the bluff’s edge toward the roadway.
  • May 2022: Following a thorough review of the report and recommendations either to close the road or pull it back 150 feet from the bluff, Parks Tacoma makes the difficult decision to close the Outer Loop permanently to all vehicles.

Are other areas of Five Mile Drive at risk?

The Department of Natural Resources mapping has long identified the Point Defiance bluff as a landslide zone and information about this risk is located throughout the park and on the Parks Tacoma website.

Can’t you shore up the slopes?

Cliff erosion at Point Defiance Park is a natural process, accelerated in recent years due to increasing rain and sea level rise from climate change. We respect this power of nature and do not work against it. Rather, we work to protect our environment and community from any harm that might come from its effects.

Is it safe to walk the beach around the Point?

While pedestrians are free to access those beaches beyond Owen Beach, the slopes above are known to be unstable. When accessing this area, it is vital to respect all posted warning signs. Attempting to climb up or down the slope is dangerous and could result not only in bodily injury, but could also accelerate erosion of this treasured natural area.

Will the Gig Harbor viewpoint restroom be open?

Yes, that restroom will be open seasonally. It is serviced via carts, to keep heavy vehicles off the roadway. The picnic shelter is also open.

Will there be any viewpoint upgrades?

Since the 2014 bond and 2015 Point Defiance Master Plan Update, we’ve been steadily improving safety and aesthetics at the viewpoints. After delays due to the pandemic, we began the process of planning the bigger upgrades which were suggested by the community in the Master Plan. Step one was consulting with Geoengineers about the slope, and now we have the confirmation that the slope is too unstable for what was hoped for. Nature is strong, and we are respecting those forces in our stewardship of public lands and assets. The picnic shelter and restrooms, which are far enough back from the bluff, will stay open to all.

What’s happening with the Loop Trail?

The Loop Trail design has changed from the original concept in the 2015 Master Plan Update, due to many factors. The biggest one was the new understanding that we would need to relocate the roadway back 150 feet from the bluff, and the substantial environmental and financial impacts that would have caused.

Like most agencies we have faced financial constraints in the wake of the pandemic. We want to offer everyone safe ways to move around the park, so we are focusing on improvements that provide pedestrians and cyclists with safe routes to experience the park’s major attractions – visitor safety is our number one objective. We will continue to explore opportunities to increase access to experience the outer forest.

Learn more about the Loop Trail

What if there’s a fire or other emergency out there?

Parks Tacoma will continue to allow fire trucks and other emergency responders along that road. We share maps and other communications with those departments to keep responders safe. Safety is our first priority.